Red wine being poured into a glass
Wine attracts more folklore than almost any other drink — and much of it is nonsense. Via Wikimedia Commons.
By the This Day in Wine History Editorial Team✓ Researched, fact-checked & verifiedAugust 20268 min read

Few drinks attract as much folklore as wine. There are rules about what to pair, how to serve, what to pay and what will give you a headache — and a surprising amount of it is simply untrue. Here are some of the most stubborn wine myths, and what the evidence actually says1.

Quick facts

  • Most wine is made to drink young — only a small share improves with age.
  • The “legs” on a glass show alcohol, not quality.
  • Screw caps are excellent closures used by many top producers.
  • White wine has more sulfites than red, so sulfites are an unlikely headache culprit.
Age
Not always better
Price
A weak guide
Sulfites
Wrongly blamed

Myth: older wine is always better

This is perhaps the most widespread wine myth of all — and it is mostly wrong. The great majority of wine is made to be enjoyed within a year or two of release, and will only get tired and dull if you keep it1. Only a small minority of wines — usually those with high tannin or acidity to preserve them — genuinely improve with long ageing. For most bottles, sooner is better than later.

Myth: the “legs” reveal quality

Swirl a glass and watch the streaks — the “legs” or “tears” — run down the side, and folklore says thicker legs mean a finer wine. They don’t. Legs are a matter of physics, not quality: they come from the different evaporation rates of alcohol and water and the surface tension between them, an effect scientists call the Gibbs–Marangoni effect2.

All the legs really tell you is that a wine is relatively high in alcohol (and sugar), which makes it more viscous. A cheap, strong wine will show splendid legs; a delicate, world-class one may show almost none3.

Myth: screw caps mean cheap wine

A wine bottle sealed with a screw cap
A screw cap — not a mark of cheap wine but an excellent closure that prevents cork taint. Via Wikimedia Commons.

Many drinkers still flinch at the twist of a screw cap, assuming cork means quality and a cap means plonk. In truth, the screw cap is an excellent closure — arguably a better one4. It seals reliably, is easy to open and reseal, and, crucially, it eliminates “cork taint,” the musty flaw caused by a compound in natural cork that ruins a noticeable share of cork-sealed bottles.

That is why screw caps have become mainstream in the New World: they account for around 90 percent of New Zealand’s wine, premium bottles included. The closure is a practical choice, not a verdict on what’s inside4.

Myth: expensive wine is always better

Surely, at least, you get what you pay for? Not reliably. In blind tastings — where the label and price are hidden — the link between what a wine costs and how much people enjoy it largely disappears, and for untrained drinkers it can even reverse, with cheaper wines scoring higher5.

This does not mean price is meaningless. Trained tasters do detect more, and up to a point you are buying real quality and complexity. But the price-to-quality curve flattens quickly — often somewhere around the modest end of the range — and beyond it you are largely paying for scarcity, prestige and a heavier bottle rather than better wine5.

Myth: sulfites cause red-wine headaches

Blaming “the sulfites” for a red-wine headache is almost a reflex — and almost certainly mistaken. The clue is simple: white wine generally contains more added sulfites than red, yet it is red wine that people blame for their headaches6.

If sulfites were the cause, whites would be the worse offenders. Researchers instead point to other suspects — alcohol itself, tannins and compounds such as histamines, plus plain dehydration — though the science is still not settled. True sulfite sensitivity is real but rare, mainly affecting some people with asthma6.

Five wine myths and what the evidence says. Sources: refs 1–6.
The mythThe reality
Older wine is always betterMost wine is best drunk young
The “legs” show qualityLegs show alcohol and viscosity, not quality
Screw caps mean cheap wineScrew caps are excellent, fault-free closures
Pricier is always betterPrice predicts enjoyment only weakly
Sulfites cause red-wine headachesWhite wine has more; other causes are likelier

Drink what you love

The thread running through every one of these myths is the same: wine is surrounded by more rules than it deserves. Age, legs, closures, price and sulfites are all far weaker guides than the folklore claims1.

The only real rule of wine is to drink what you love.— the truth behind the myths1

The genuinely useful knowledge — which wines age, why a wine tastes as it does, how to store a bottle — is worth learning. The rest is noise. Trust your own palate, pour what you enjoy, and let the myths run down the side of the glass like so many meaningless tears.

Frequently asked questions

Is older wine always better?

No. Most wine is made to be drunk within a year or two of release and does not improve with age. Only a minority of wines, usually high in tannin or acidity, genuinely benefit from long ageing.

Do wine “legs” indicate quality?

No. Legs, or tears, are caused by the different evaporation rates of alcohol and water (the Gibbs–Marangoni effect). They indicate a wine’s alcohol and viscosity, not its quality.

Are screw-cap wines lower quality than corked ones?

Not at all. Screw caps are reliable closures that prevent cork taint, and they are used for many premium wines — around 90% of New Zealand’s wine, for example. The closure says nothing about quality.

Does more expensive wine always taste better?

No. In blind tastings the link between price and enjoyment is weak and can even reverse. Quality does rise with price up to a point, but the curve flattens quickly and higher prices largely reflect scarcity and prestige.

Do sulfites cause red-wine headaches?

Probably not. White wine usually contains more sulfites than red, yet red is blamed for headaches. Alcohol, tannins, histamines and dehydration are more likely causes, though the science is not settled.

Do you have to let wine “breathe” or decant it?

Only sometimes. A short spell of aeration or decanting can help some young, tannic reds, but simply pulling the cork and leaving the bottle standing does almost nothing.

More from this day in wine history

See everything else that happened on February 8 — who was born, what was bottled, and which laws were signed.

Explore February 8 →

Read more

References

  1. Wine & Spirit Education Trust (WSET) — Six common wine myths debunked. ↑
  2. Wine Folly — What Do Wine Legs Really Mean? ↑
  3. Decanter — Do wine legs mean a better wine? ↑
  4. Wine Folly — Corks vs Screw Caps. ↑
  5. Journal of Wine Economics (Cambridge) — Wine as an Experience Good: price versus enjoyment in blind tastings. ↑
  6. Medical News Today — Do Sulfites in Wine Cause Headaches? ↑

Recommended reading

Vintage: The Story of Wine

Vintage: The Story of Wine

Hugh Johnson
A wise, myth-busting history of wine from one of its greatest and most sensible writers.
A History of the World in 6 Glasses

A History of the World in 6 Glasses

Tom Standage
A clear-eyed look at how humans have understood — and misunderstood — their favourite drinks.

As an Amazon Associate, This Day in Wine History earns from qualifying purchases. Book recommendations are chosen independently.

Categories: This Day in Wine History | ArticlesTags: , , , , , , By Published On: February 8, 2023Last Updated: August 14, 2026

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!