A monk sampling wine, medieval illumination
A monk sampling wine from a barrel, medieval illumination | Public domain (Wikimedia Commons)

By Ken Wytsma · Researched, fact-checked & verified by the TDIWH Editorial Team.

Long before California beat France at a Paris tasting in 1976, a French poet imagined a different kind of wine contest: a war. Around 1224, in a comic poem, the wines of Europe are summoned to court and judged by a single, spectacularly drunk English priest, who excommunicates the bad ones and crowns a champion.

Key takeaways

  • Around 1224, the poet Henri d’Andeli wrote La Bataille des Vins, staging a mock war of some seventy wines at the court of the French king Philip II Augustus.
  • A single English priest judges the field, “excommunicating” the sour and unhealthy wines and elevating the good ones to noble and Church rank.
  • The sweet wine of Cyprus is crowned apostoile — the pope of wines — a title that in Old French means the pope, not, as sometimes translated, the apostle.
  • It is often called the earliest surviving comparative ranking of wines, a distant ancestor of the modern wine competition — though it is a satirical poem, not a real tasting.

A war of wines

Henri d’Andeli was a Norman cleric and poet of the early thirteenth century, and La Bataille des Vins is his lightest, sharpest work: a little over two hundred lines of rhyming verse in which King Philip II Augustus assembles the wines of the known world and puts them to war. Chablis, Beaune, Champagne, Saint-Émilion, Sancerre, Alsace, the wines of the Moselle, of Spain, of Cyprus — some seventy in all — are lined up to be judged.

The judge is an English priest, named a master of wine-drinking, and he goes at the work with relish. The wines he finds too sour or unwholesome are excommunicated — in the original he beats them off with a short stick — while the great wines are raised up, made cardinals and legates and kings and counts, the twelve peers of a realm of wine.

It is a medieval hierarchy, the Church and the court, mapped onto a wine list. And it is very funny, which is the point.

Ranking wine: from a medieval poem to Parisc.1224Henri d'Andeli's Battle of theWines crowns a Cyprus wine.1855The Bordeaux classificationranks the wines of the Médoc.1976The Judgment of Paris: Californiabeats France in a blind tasting.Sources: remacle.org (Old French text); Wine Spectator. This Day in Wine History.
The long line from a medieval poem to the Judgment of Paris. | This Day in Wine History

Assemble the wines, appoint a judge, rank them, crown a champion. In 1224 the winner wore a papal tiara and the judge drank himself under the table.

The pope of wines

At the top of that hierarchy the poet places the sweet wine of Cyprus, which he crowns apostoile, “who shone like a star.” The word is worth pausing on. In Old French apostoile means the pope, the apostolic one, not the apostle as it is sometimes rendered. So the poem does not make the Cyprus wine an apostle of wines. It makes it the pope of them, enthroned above the cardinals and kings.

That sweet Cypriot wine is widely believed to be an ancestor of Commandaria, the honeyed wine Cyprus still makes. The poem does not name Commandaria; the link is a later inference. But the instinct behind the ranking is one any wine drinker knows: line them up, argue, and crown a favourite.

The English priest, for his part, does not survive his own judging. Played throughout as a sozzled buffoon, he slurs and insults the wines and finally falls down dead drunk before the contest ends — a French joke about English drinking that was already old in 1224.

The ancestor of the competition

Call it what it is and it is remarkable enough. This is not an empirical tasting, with samples poured and scored. It is a satirical poem, an armchair ranking of wines by reputation, dressed as a war. We will never know how many of its verdicts reflected real thirteenth-century taste and how many served the joke.

And yet the shape is unmistakable. Assemble the wines, appoint a judge, rank them, crown a champion. Seven and a half centuries later, Steven Spurrier assembled French and Californian bottles in Paris, appointed judges, and let them score in the tasting now called the Judgment of Paris. The poem is the comic ancestor; the 1976 tasting is the empirical heir.

One line runs between them, and it is a very human one: the wish to put wines side by side and decide, once and for all, which is best. In 1224 the winner wore a papal tiara and the judge drank himself under the table. The impulse has not changed. Only the paperwork has.

Quick facts

  • The work: La Bataille des Vins (“The Battle of the Wines”), a poem of ~200 verses
  • The poet: Henri d’Andeli, a 13th-century Norman cleric
  • Date: c. 1224 (just after the death of Philip II Augustus in 1223)
  • The setting: The court of King Philip II Augustus of France
  • The judge: An English priest who excommunicates bad wines and ennobles good ones
  • The field: Around 70 wines, mostly white, from across Europe
  • The winner: The sweet wine of Cyprus, crowned apostoile — pope of wines
  • Modern echo: The 1976 Judgment of Paris, its empirical descendant

This day in wine history

  • 1223 — Philip II Augustus, the king at whose court the poem is set, dies; the work is written just after.
  • c. 1224 — Henri d’Andeli composes La Bataille des Vins, crowning the sweet wine of Cyprus pope of wines.
  • 1855 — France’s Bordeaux classification ranks the wines of the Médoc, a later formal league table of wine.
  • 24 May 1976 — The Judgment of Paris: a blind tasting in which California wines beat French ones, the modern heir to the medieval contest.

Frequently asked questions

What was the “Battle of the Wines”?

It was a comic French poem, La Bataille des Vins, written around 1224 by Henri d’Andeli. In it, King Philip II Augustus summons about seventy wines from across Europe and has an English priest judge them, excommunicating the bad wines and crowning a champion.

Which wine won?

The sweet wine of Cyprus, which the poem crowns apostoile — the pope of wines. That Cypriot wine is widely believed to be an ancestor of Commandaria, though the poem itself does not use that name.

Was it a real wine tasting?

No. It is a satirical poem, an allegorical ranking of wines by reputation dressed as a mock war — not an empirical tasting with samples poured and scored. It is often called the earliest surviving comparative ranking of wines, which makes it a distant ancestor of the modern competition rather than the first tasting itself.

How does it connect to the Judgment of Paris?

Both line wines up, appoint judges, and crown a champion. The 1224 poem is the comic, literary ancestor; the 1976 Judgment of Paris — where California wines beat French ones in a blind tasting — is its empirical descendant. The link is a theme modern writers draw, not a claim the medieval poem makes.

Read more

For more of wine’s stranger corners, explore our Turning Points in Wine History collection at This Day in Wine History.

Further reading

As an Amazon Associate, This Day in Wine History earns from qualifying purchases. Book links are affiliate links; cover images are used for identification.

Hugh Johnson's The Story of Wine — book cover

Hugh Johnson’s The Story of Wine
Hugh Johnson
Sweeping cultural history of wine from antiquity through medieval Europe.
Inventing Wine: A New History of One of the World's Most Ancient Pleasures — book cover

Inventing Wine: A New History of One of the World’s Most Ancient Pleasures
Paul Lukacs
New history tracing wine’s evolution across cultures, including medieval European drinking.

Sources

  1. Henri d’Andeli, La Bataille des Vins — original Old French text (source of “Vin de Cypre fist apostoile”). remacle.org
  2. La Bataille des vins — French Wikisource text and editorial notice (204 verses, named regions). wikisource.org
  3. “The First Wine Competition?” Wine Spectator — date, the field of ~70 wines, and the Cyprus “pope” (competition framing). winespectator.com
  4. “The Battle of Wines: Factual or Mythical?” This Day in Wine History — the drunk priest and the factual-versus-mythical caveat. thisdayinwinehistory.com
  5. “Philip II, king of France,” Encyclopaedia Britannica — his reign, 1180–1223 (the date-versus-reign context). britannica.com

Love the stories where wine and history collide?
Explore This Day in Wine History — a new story every few days.

Categories: Wine and WarTags: , , , , By Published On: October 16, 2026Last Updated: July 30, 2026

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!